Creating Usable Policies for Stronger Passwords with MTurk.pdf (3.67 MB)
Download file

Creating Usable Policies for Stronger Passwords with MTurk

Download (3.67 MB)
thesis
posted on 01.02.2015, 00:00 by Richard Shay

People are living increasingly large swaths of their lives through their online accounts. These accounts are brimming with sensitive data, and they are often protected only by a text password. Attackers can break into service providers and steal the hashed password files that store users’ passwords. This lets attackers make a large number of guesses to crack users’ passwords. The stronger a password is, the more difficult it is for an attacker to guess. Many service providers have implemented password-composition policies. These policies constrain or restrict passwords in order to prevent users from creating easily guessed passwords. Too lenient a policy may permit easily cracked passwords, and too strict a policy may encumber users. The ideal password-composition policy balances security and usability. Prior to the work in this thesis, many password-composition policies were based on heuristics and speculation, rather than scientific analysis. Passwords research often examined passwords constructed under a single uniform policy, or constructed under unknown policies. In this thesis, I contrast the strength and usability of passwords created under different policies. I do this through online, crowdsourced human-subjects studies with randomized, controlled password-composition policies. This result is a scientific comparison of how different password-composition policies affect both password strength and usability. I studied a range of policies, including those similar to policies found in the wild, policies that trade usability for security by requiring longer passwords, and policies in which passwords are system-assigned with known security. One contribution of this thesis is a tested methodology for collecting passwords under different policies. Another contribution is the comparison between password policies. I find that some password-composition policies make more favorable tradeoffs between security and usability, allowing evidence-based recommendations for service providers. I also offer insights for researchers interested in conducting larger-scale online studies, having collected data from tens of thousands of participants.

History

Date

01/02/2015

Degree Type

Dissertation

Department

Institute for Software Research

Degree Name

Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)

Advisor(s)

Lorrie Faith Cranor

Usage metrics

Exports